The response to my question to Cllr Lynden Stowe for the Cotswold District Council Council meeting on Tuesday 18th October 2011
‘First, I am concerned that you do not yet appear to appreciate the difference between personal and prejudicial interests, or the reasons why Members are required to declare their interests. I am suggesting to the Monitoring Officer that a further induction session for new Members might be appropriate – which you may like to attend.
Secondly, the approved minutes of the Cabinet meeting do not accord with your recollection. The minimum number of Cabinet Members present for any item on the September Cabinet agenda was four, despite two Members of Cabinet being unable to be present.
As regards to grant funding provided by this Council, the outcomes are what matters and these are monitored and agreed with Council officers. The Council’s grant is, of course, only a part of the income that those grant-aided organisations receive. Those organisations have their own procurement policies and the Council has no control over who may be a supplier to those organisations. If those organisations wish to use the services of local companies based in the Cotswolds that is their choice, but one which I’m sure we would all welcome. Likewise I’m sure that any organisation who uses the services of any business which I am involved in – or indeed any other Member is involved in – will have done so on the basis that it quoted the best price in a competitive market-place.
You are also wrong to make an assumption that because I/my colleagues declare a prejudicial interest then it means we receive money from an organisation. By way of example, the declarations of interest made in respect of Chipping Campden Tourist Information Centre were not made in respect of money we receive from them – to the contrary, the project we handle – publishing the Chipping Campden Town Guide – raises revenue for the Tourist Information Centre.
I would also refer you to previous answers that I have given to other Members of your group on the same subject at Council/Cabinet meetings on 5th February, 20th April and 9th September 2010. You will find copies on the Council’s website.’
A very patronizing answer to the youngest member of the Council, however he still hadn’t answered the question so I followed up with the following supplementary:
I’d like to thank Cllr Stowe for his response but does the Leader understand that, with answers like that, it is understandable why the young people of this country are turned off by politics and the conduct of politicians? People of my age are constantly told to seek role models who they can look up to and emulate. But since arriving here I can see why so many young people don’t even bother to vote.
Campden VIC, Cotswold Conservation Board, CDC itself, Brewery Arts, Cotswold Water Park Society, West Oxfordshire District Council – all organisations that receive local taxpayers money, some of which eventually finds its way to companies owned by the Leader.
Will he accept that it may be perfectly legal and that all he and his Cotswold Media Colleagues need to do is to constantly jump up and nip out of the room ……….but it simply looks awful?
Nothing could have prepared members for the onslaught that followed. An immature rant about the merry bandwagon of Lib Dems on CDC.
“The situation is that I know that me and my colleagues have always declared proper personal and prejudicial interests in any item that has come before this Council. That is what is relevant. We have done everything by the book. So the same applies – put it ion the table. Let’s have your evidence before you again join the merry bandwagon of Liberal Democrats having a crack at us. Put it on the table. I want to put another perspective here. Do you know, businesses which I’m involved in – and let’s get this straight – I’m not the majority shareholder as there are other people who make decisions with regard to that business. It’s not for me to override them and put into the public domain that doesn’t need to be put into the public domain. We employ 23 people, those people have families, they are based in the Cotswolds. We are a Cotswolds business. Those people pay council tax. Right? They pay other taxes; income tax, VAT, other taxes. They pay part of your allowance, Councillor Harris. Those people want to know what’s the game? No – shut up! I’m doing this question. They want to know what’s the game? Why are they reading about attacks on their business?”
Unfortunately for the residents of the Cotswolds a significantly reduced majority for the Tories on CDC seems to have changed little. Looks like we’re going to have to work hard in 2015 to win Cotswold District Council and ensure fairness prevails!
Click here to view a video response about the meeting from myself and Cllr John Hughes (Beeches) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_g9ootiWzU&feature=related